Putting God to the Test
The author of Hebrews defines faith as “confidence in what we hope for and assurance for what we do not see” (Hebrews 11:1). You don’t need faith for what you already see, that is just sight. Faith is trusting in God even when things don’t look right or when we can’t see what the outcome will be.
Another definition of faith I have been pondering is “putting God to the test.” This might sound strange if you are more familiar with the bible. When Jesus was tempted by Satan in the wilderness one of the ways he responded was by quoting Deuteronomy 6:16, “Do not put the Lord your God to the test” (Matthew 4:7). If Jesus explicitly tells us not to put God to the test, why would I argue that putting God to the test is actually an expression of faith?
I will start by showing how it is wrong to put God to the test, then show how it is right to put God to the test, and conclude with some ways you could apply this to your life.
When Testing God is Wrong
For the second temptation of Christ, Satan took Jesus to the highest point in the temple in Jerusalem and said, “If you are the Son of God throw yourself down. For it is written, ‘He will command his angels concerning you, and they will lift you up in their hands, so that you will not strike your foot against a stone'” (Matthew 4:5-6).
This is where Jesus responded, “It is also written, ‘Do not put the Lord your God to the test.'”
Why would this have been wrong for Jesus to jump? Didn’t he trust that God would protect him until his time was at hand? I think there are a couple reasons why jumping would have been wrong.
First, God the Father already proclaimed the identity of “beloved son” over Jesus (Matthew 3:17). Satan was trying to make Jesus prove his sonship rather than trusting the Father’s words. If you take God at his word, you won’t need to push the boundaries. This is similar to Satan’s temptation of Adam and Eve, “Did God really say . . .?” (Genesis 3:1). Adam and Eve tested whether or not they would die after eating the forbidden fruit.
Imagine you went to a wedding where the wife told the husband that she would love him and stick by him no matter what. Then the husband wanted to see if she really meant it. Will she stay if I stop helping around the house? Will she stay if I cheat on her? Will she stay if I become abusive? This is not how you treat someone you love. It is one thing for the husband to be honest about his shortcomings and quite another thing to intentionally push the boundaries of what his wife can endure.
Second, Satan is trying to get Jesus to go beyond what the Father called him to do. Jesus did not frequent the big cities. He did most of his ministry in small towns, attracting crowds of poor and desperate people. He often did things to avoid the praise of people. He said that he only came to earth to do the will of his Father. God never called Jesus to make himself a spectacle. Rather, God called Jesus to serve, bring restoration and healing, and ultimately die on the cross for the sins of humanity. Jesus knew that Satan’s temptation was beyond what God called him to do.
An example from my life where I foolishly put God to the test was my senior year of high school. I was new to my faith and didn’t have much guidance, so I attempted to do both football and cross country in the same season. I reasoned that it shouldn’t be possible for anyone to do both sports, so if I succeeded I would have used that as evidence for God’s strength and power.
Unsurprisingly, this experiment failed after a couple weeks. My body could not handle the strain because it was never meant to. In hindsight I should have realized that God made me to play football and invested my energy into doing the best I could on the field and loving my teammates and coaches. I didn’t test God by thinking, “God isn’t real unless he empowers me to do both sports.” But I did think that God needed my help to let others see his greatness (which he didn’t). I didn’t trust that God would work through my simple obedience. I believe I would have had a bigger impact if I was more intentional with those who were already in my sphere of influence, rather than trying to have God turn me into Superman.
Testing God is wrong when it takes the place of trusting God. Testing God is right when it is a means of trusting God.
When Testing God is Right
About 25% of the book of Genesis is devoted to Abraham. God called Abraham to leave his family and town and go to the land that God would show him. Abraham had many inspiring examples of faith, and some significant moral failures. After 25 years of waiting, God miraculously gave Abraham a son, through whom the whole world would be blessed.
However, Genesis 22 states, “Some time later God tested Abraham.” He told him, “Take your son, your only son, who you love — Isaac– and go to the region of Moriah. Sacrifice him there as a burnt offering on a mountain I will show you.”
And Abraham obeyed.
He and Isaac climbed the mountain, Isaac carrying the wood and Abraham carrying the knife and fire. After building an altar, Abraham tied up his beloved son and raised the knife to slay his child . . .
The text states that God tested Abraham, but I think Abraham was also testing God.
God clearly promised that the covenant would be established through Isaac as an everlasting covenant for his descendents after him (Genesis 17:19). Abraham is holding two things in tension. On the one hand, Isaac is the one through whom the blessing of the whole world was to come. On the other hand, God commanded Abraham to kill his son. There were only four options for this tension to be resolved:
- Abraham refuses to obey God.
- God lets Isaac die, thus showing that he does not keep his promises (thus not worthy of our worship).
- Abraham goes through with killing Isaac, then God raises him from the dead.
- God prevents Abraham from killing his son and provides a substitute (which is what happened).
Abraham was testing God to stay true to his promise even if it meant doing the impossible (raising the dead). Abraham was obedient to the point of giving up what he loved most because he believed that God was trustworthy.
Notice, the only reason Abraham went through with the sacrifice was because God commanded him. He did not attempt to sacrifice his son to see if God would stop it. That would have been putting God to the test in the negative way we discussed above.
To summarize, testing God is wrong when it takes the place of trusting God. But, testing God is right when it is a means of trusting God. Below are some examples of how this type of faith can be lived out today.
Positive Examples of Putting God to the Test
- Giving generously, trusting that God will provide you with everything you need (Mat 6:25-34).
- Sharing the gospel with a hardened atheist, trusting that God has the power to change any heart (1 Tim 1:15).
- Persevering when things seem unbearable because God promised to work things out for good for those who love him (Rom 8:28).
- Forgiving someone rather than seeking revenge because you trust in God’s divine justice (Rom 12:19).
- Sharing a hard truth with someone because it is impossible to please God and people (Gal 1:10).
- Praying even when you don’t feel like it, trusting that God hears and cares (1 Peter 5:7).
- Taking a professional risk, resting in the fact that you’re worth is not found in success.
- Sticking with those who are wandering in their faith, because the God who began a good work in them will carry it on to completion (Phil 1:6).
- Many Christians throughout the centuries have been martyred because they trusted that eternal life in God’s paradise was worth more than the world could offer them.
Imagine a man who was considering going skydiving. How would we know that he had faith that his parachute would open?
Only if he jumps. He can talk all he wants about how great the parachute is, but until he jumps out of the plane and puts it to the test, he doesn’t really trust it. It is the same with God. We might say we trust him, but until we jump out of the plane and take part in risky obedience, our words are empty. “Faith without works is dead (James 2:17).
May God give us this type of faith!















